Black laser toner cartridge on a light surface with an office printer blurred in the background.
Article · Printing blog

HP LaserJet Pro M404/M428 compatible toner: 59A guide

Updated

The HP LaserJet Pro M404 and MFP M428 can use different cartridge references depending on the complete model and region. Before choosing 59A or 59X, read the installed cartridge code, identify the exact printer variant, and check the official documentation. The shortened M404 or M428 family name is not enough.

Key points
- HP assigns 58A/58X to certain North and Latin American variants and 59A/59X to EMEA variants; they are not universally interchangeable (HP M404; HP M428).
- HP rates 59A at about 3,000 pages and 59X at about 10,000 under ISO/IEC 19752 (HP); the standard uses a defined test page, not a universal 5% rule.
- Compare current cost per page instead of relying on fixed prices or savings percentages.
- Dynamic Security may reject a non-HP chip now or after an update; no chip can guarantee a permanent bypass (HP).

Which toner do the HP LaserJet Pro M404 and MFP M428 need?

For documented variants in Europe, the Middle East, Russia, CIS, and Africa, HP identifies the 59A (CF259A), rated at about 3,000 pages, and the 59X (CF259X), rated at about 10,000 under ISO/IEC 19752 (HP). North and Latin America use 58A/58X; Asia-Pacific except China and India uses 76A/76X.

A compatible toner is a third-party supply, not an Original HP cartridge. Its construction, chip, stated yield, and firmware behavior depend on the specific product. Physical fit or a shared family name does not replace checking the cartridge reference, region, exact printer variant, and the seller's current product page.

Watch out for the 58A / 59A trap

The cartridge reference is regional, not a free choice between names. HP documents 58A/58X for North and Latin America, 59A/59X for Europe, the Middle East, Russia, CIS, and Africa, and 76A/76X for Asia-Pacific except China and India (HP M404; HP M428). A reference assigned to another region may not be suitable; check the full printer model before buying.

Read the installed cartridge label and the printer's complete product identification. Then check HP's regional table and the exact compatible product page. Do not switch from 58 to 59, or from 59 to 58, merely because both listings mention M404 or M428; the correct reference depends on variant and market.

Reference Code Approx. original yield Recommended use
HP 58A CF258A ~3,000 Medium volume
HP 58X CF258X ~10,000 High volume
HP 59A CF259A ~3,000 Medium volume
HP 59X CF259X 10,000 High volume

Which printers are compatible with the CF259A?

This store's compatible CF259A page lists exactly six variants: M404n, M404dn, M404dw, M428dw, M428fdn, and M428fdw (CF259A listing). That list defines the advertised scope of this SKU; it does not prove universal acceptance and must not be extended to the Enterprise M406 or M430.

If your printer is one of those six models, also confirm that it is a 59A/59X regional variant and that the installed code is CF259A or CF259X. The n, dn, dw, and fdw suffixes identify configurations, but do not override regional locking. Research any unlisted variant separately before ordering.

A useful check is specific and document-based: complete model, region, printed cartridge reference, firmware version, and the product page's current terms. A test in one printer cannot guarantee behavior in every unit or with future firmware. Keep the cartridge label and exact on-screen message if recognition fails.

Does the compatible yield fewer pages than the original?

Not as a universal claim. HP rates the Original 59A at about 3,000 pages and the Original 59X at about 10,000 pages under ISO/IEC 19752 (HP). A compatible cartridge's yield must come from its own listing and test method; do not transfer another seller's yield figure to this product.

How to read the figure: ISO/IEC 19752 uses a defined test page, controlled conditions, and an end-of-life criterion. ISO explains that the standard replaced the old fixed 5% coverage comparison with a common test page (ISO). Your documents, settings, and environment can produce a different result.

See our cartridge-yield guide for more on why a stated yield is a comparison reference rather than a promise for every user.

How much do you save with the compatible? The cost per page

There is no permanent price or savings percentage. Cost changes with country, tax, promotion, and seller. For a useful comparison, take the current price of the original and the compatible intended for your exact model and region, then divide each by its stated yield under the disclosed test method.

Use this table as a comparison formula, not a price list or savings promise:

Cartridge Current price Stated yield Cost per page
CF259A original Original price today 3,000 price ÷ ~3,000
CF259A compatible Compatible price today Per SKU listing price ÷ stated yield

The results are comparable only when the calculations use prices from the same market, treat taxes consistently, and rely on documented yields. Recalculate when prices change. To include paper, power, and maintenance, use our guide to the real cost of printing with your office's actual data.

Verifiable basis: HP publishes about 3,000 pages for the Original 59A (HP). For a compatible, use the current point-of-sale price and a yield documented specifically for that product, not a third party's figure. Current inputs let you calculate cost per page, but not promise a fixed savings percentage.

Why does my HP printer reject the compatible toner?

A rejection can result from the wrong reference or region, poor seating, damaged contacts, an unrecognized chip, a defective supply, or Dynamic Security. HP says cartridges with non-HP chips may not work, and one that works now may stop after authentication changes (HP).

The message therefore does not by itself prove that HP deliberately blocked an otherwise correct cartridge, nor that toner powder is the cause. Record the exact wording, confirm CF259A versus CF258A, verify the regional variant, and follow the manual's installation checks. Only then consider firmware, seller support, or replacement.

What to check if the M404/M428 rejects a compatible

Check these points without assuming a guaranteed fix:

  1. Confirm model, region, and reference. Match the printer and cartridge labels against HP's regional table and the exact product page.
  2. Reinstall it as the manual directs. Power down only if instructed, remove every shipping seal, inspect visible contacts without damaging them, and reseat the cartridge.
  3. Review the message and firmware context. Consult the model documentation and Dynamic Security terms (HP). Do not disable security or install unofficial firmware in expectation of a guaranteed bypass.

None of these steps guarantees acceptance of a non-HP chip. If the warning persists, photograph the message and ask the seller to verify the SKU. Read our guides to HP firmware and toner recognition errors for further diagnosis; neither promises a universal fix.

Should I choose the 59A or the 59X?

Choose capacity only after confirming that your regional variant accepts the 59 family. HP rates 59A at about 3,000 pages and 59X at about 10,000 pages under ISO/IEC 19752 (HP). The X version reduces replacement frequency, but does not make 58 and 59 interchangeable.

Estimate monthly volume and divide current price by stated yield. High capacity may suit heavier use when the printer accepts that reference; standard capacity can reduce initial spend. This guide to choosing the right toner helps organize the check, but the cartridge label and HP's regional documentation determine compatibility.

How do I know the compatible I'm buying comes with an updated chip?

There is no way to guarantee that a chip will remain accepted by every future firmware version. Ask the seller for the batch reference, covered models and regions, and its current process for a rejection. HP warns that authentication can change during the printer's life (HP).

Save the product page and firmware version at the time of purchase. If recognition later fails, send the exact message and those details to the seller. An 'updated chip' description reports the product's present state; it is not a promise of bypass, permanent compatibility, automatic replacement, or printer coverage.

Before ordering, read our guide to buying affordable toner safely. Check concrete specifications and published terms, not absolute firmware or warranty claims.

Buying the right compatible CF259A

Confirm four items: complete printer model, region, installed code, and supported capacity. For this CF259A SKU, limit the check to M404n, M404dn, M404dw, M428dw, M428fdn, and M428fdw. Do not extend the listing to M406, M430, or a printer configured for 58A/58X.

Use the compatible CF259A product page only to identify this SKU and its six listed models. Compare it with HP's regional documentation. Do not treat the seller listing as proof of universal acceptance, actual yield, firmware immunity, savings, warranty coverage, or compatibility with models it does not list. See also our compatible HP toner collection.

Frequently asked questions

Does the compatible CF259A work for the M404 and the M428?

This CF259A product page lists six variants: M404n, M404dn, M404dw, M428dw, M428fdn, and M428fdw. That defines the SKU's model list, not universal acceptance. Also confirm that your printer is a 59A/59X regional variant using CF259A. Do not extend the list to M406, M430, or regional 58A/58X models.

How much do I save using the compatible instead of the original?

Divide the price by the stated page yield and compare that cost per page with the original. Use current prices from the same market and treat taxes consistently. HP rates the original 59A at about 3,000 pages; check the compatible's stated yield separately. No fixed saving is guaranteed because documents and printing conditions can change actual yield.

What do I do if "Non-HP Chip Detected" appears?

First record the exact message and confirm model, region, and cartridge reference, then reinstall the supply as the manual directs. The warning identifies a non-HP chip but does not prove its cause. HP says Dynamic Security may prevent operation now or after later changes. Contact the seller if the warning remains.

Is the difference between 59A and 59X only the yield?

Mainly, their stated capacity differs: HP rates 59A at about 3,000 pages and 59X at about 10,000 under ISO/IEC 19752. Still confirm that your regional printer variant accepts the selected reference. The standard uses a defined test page, not a universal 5% coverage rule, and actual yield can vary.

What coverage applies to the compatible and the printer?

In Spain, Article 120.1 gives consumers conformity rights for a cartridge when a defect existing at delivery appears within three years. Those rights do not guarantee printer repair. HP says using a non-HP cartridge alone does not void the printer warranty, but damage attributable to that cartridge is excluded. Keep the invoice and diagnosis.

Sources

Was this article helpful?

Back to blog