real cost per page of printing with original vs compatible cartridges
Article · Printing blog

How to estimate printing cost per page

Updated

To estimate consumable cost per printed page, divide the price you actually paid for the exact cartridge by its catalog-declared page yield. The quotient is an estimate, not a promise of real output or total printing cost. Paper, electricity, drums, maintenance parts and the printer itself are excluded; check them separately for your model.

How to calculate the estimate

Estimated consumable cost per page = price paid for the exact cartridge ÷ its catalog-declared page yield. Use the same currency, tax basis and print type when comparing two offers. Actual yield depends on documents and usage, so keep the result separate from your full cost of ownership.

Worked example: four dated Spanish offers

The four rows below reproduce the published Spanish comparison captured on 27 September 2026. The Startoner prices were checked against the matching catalog products; the original prices and declared yields are shown on the linked official manufacturer stores. These are dated prices, not offers for every country or a prediction of your actual page yield.

Cartridge referenceStartoner priceOEM priceCatalog-declared yieldEstimate per page: Startoner / OEMOfficial OEM store
Brother TN-348014.98 €206.17 €8,0000.001873 € / 0.025771 €https://store.brother.es/supplies/laser/toner/tn/tn3480
HP W1490A (149A)16.98 €148.49 €2,9000.005855 € / 0.051203 €https://www.hp.com/es-es/shop/products/supplies/cartucho-de-t-ner-original-hp-149a-negro-w1490a
HP CF289A (89A)49.98 €224.00 €5,0000.009996 € / 0.044800 €https://www.hp.com/es-es/shop/products/supplies/cartucho-de-t-ner-original-hp-89a-negro-cf289a
Canon 3009C002 (057)35.98 €139.99 €3,1000.011606 € / 0.045158 €https://www.canon.es/store/canon-cartucho-de-toner-canon-i-sensys-057-negro/3009C002/

All amounts are in euros, as captured for Spain on 27 September 2026. Dividing each price by the stated yield gives a cartridge-only estimate. Check current prices and compatibility before ordering.

Checklist for your exact printer model

Before choosing a printer or replacement cartridge, record:

  • The printer purchase price and the exact compatible cartridge reference.
  • The current price and catalog-declared yield of each cartridge you would actually buy.
  • Whether the model uses a separate drum or other replaceable maintenance parts, and their prices.
  • Your expected pages per month, colour versus mono mix, and paper and electricity costs.

HP firmware and cartridge choice

HP says some printers use Dynamic Security, which can reject cartridges with non-HP chips or circuitry; authentication can change after a firmware update. HP also says online update settings depend on the printer and services used. Check the exact model documentation before buying a cartridge. This is not an instruction or promise that Dynamic Security can be switched off in a menu.

Warranty and EU legal guarantee

HP states that using a non-HP cartridge alone does not void its limited printer warranty, but failure or damage attributable to that cartridge is excluded from that warranty. Separately, Directive (EU) 2019/771 gives consumers a legal conformity guarantee against the seller for goods; national rules may provide longer protection. The two protections are different, so check the seller and manufacturer terms for your purchase.

Frequently asked questions

How do I estimate cartridge cost per page?

Divide the price you paid for the exact cartridge by its catalog-declared page yield. For example, a €16.98 cartridge with a declared 2,900-page yield gives about €0.005855 per page. This is a consumable-only estimate, not your total printing cost or a guaranteed output. Paper, electricity, drums and the printer are separate costs.

Can I use the four example prices for my own purchase?

Use them as a dated Spanish example, not as today’s price in every market. The four rows were captured on 27 September 2026 and use the catalog-declared yield for each reference. Check the current checkout price, tax, exact cartridge fit and maintenance parts for your printer. Then repeat the division using your own figures.

Will an HP firmware update reject a compatible cartridge?

It can on some models. HP says Dynamic Security uses cartridge chips or circuitry and that authentication may change after firmware updates. This does not mean every HP printer or every compatible cartridge is affected. Look up your exact printer model and cartridge requirements in HP documentation; online update settings also vary by model and connected service.

Does a non-HP cartridge cancel the printer warranty or EU rights?

Not by itself under HP’s limited warranty: HP says damage attributable to a non-HP cartridge is excluded, but merely using one does not void the printer warranty. The EU legal conformity guarantee under Directive (EU) 2019/771 concerns the seller of the goods, not an automatic extension of HP’s voluntary warranty. Check the applicable national rules and your purchase terms.

Sources and capture date

Official manufacturer product pages for the 27 September 2026 Spanish price snapshot, plus HP and European Commission explanations:

Was this article helpful?

Back to blog